How do you evaluate a robot before deploying it?
Evaluate a robot against six conditions rather than against a demonstration: can it physically act where the work is, can it finish without a human at every step, is it authorised and by whom, can it be paid, who answers when it fails, and can one operator run a hundred. A vendor demonstration answers the first two. The other four decide whether a pilot becomes a deployment, and they are the ones to put in writing before signing anything.
The working
The questions to ask in the room
Show me the record of who authorised this machine to perform this task. Revoke it now and show me the machine stop. Name the person accountable if it damages something. Tell me what happens when the tenth unit arrives and the engineer who configured the first has left. Every one of those has an answer, and the answer is usually silence, which is itself the finding.
Scoring rather than judging
Score each condition 0 to 3 against a published rubric and write the reasoning down. A total is a summary, not a decision — read down your own binding constraint instead. A platform scoring well overall but failing on fleet is unusable if you cannot staff a handler per machine, and a platform failing on embodiment is fine if the work is stationary.
Sources: ISO 10218 — industrial robots, safety requirements. Dated 2026-08-28; superseded by publishing a new answer, never by editing this one.
Related
Liability for a robot falls on whoever authorised it to act — but establishing that requires the authorisation to have been recorded at the time, to h…
AnswerWhich robots are actually deployed commercially today?Commercially deployed robotics is dominated by two categories: fixed industrial arms in manufacturing cells, and autonomous mobile robots in warehouse…
The frameworkThe six conditionsWhat every answer here is measured against, with the rubric published.